I have has the case 2 weeks. It seemed a tight fit to start but though it might be ok, today I noticed that it has cracked where it is the tightest on the phone and is obviously these are stress fractures. This has not been dropped and is inside a pouch for extra protection. It allows ease of use with buttons but if it doesn't protect and breaks that is pointless. Have read similar reviews but ignored them as these were from auction site so thought they could be fake products but obviously not.